Sam Elzoul
The free will debate is basiclly a debate on what is the ultimit cause of human actions. There are two different types of causes. The first type of cause is Libertarians which they believe some of our actions are generated by free will and soem of them are generated by external causes. The secound type of human action is called Determinists which believes all our actions are generated by external causes such as the phyical world or the enviorment one was raised. I believe that the determinists is more reasonable which is why i agree with the determinists beliefs.
(A) I believe that Determinists explain more types of Human behavior than libertarians. The reason why i believe that is if you think about if everyone had free will and wanted to do what they wanted alot of people would be the same type of person but since there is no free will this is why there is different people in the world. Even if there is free will people couldn't change there life if they wanted to because they think they did but they didn't like have you ever heard that saying everything happens for a reason that reason is because it was already suppose to happen people can't change what's going to happen to them even if they did it was meant to happen. The types of theoires that Libertarians fail to address is when you're doing somthing like playing video games or doing laundry why there doing it.
(B) Yes i believe that determinsts explain the causes of human behavior in greater detail the Libertarians. The reason why i believe this is because determinists expalin that everything is caused by external world and the eniverment one was raised and i agree with that because why else would be here no has a reason why we were brought to this world. And Libertarians just believe we do stuff just to do it basically which isn't really an explanation. Which is why i believe Derterminsts expalains the Human cause more.
(C) Yes some theories from libertarians have fewer parts than determinists and i say this because it dosen't give a reason on why we do stuff yes they say we have free will but what is the meaning of doing what were doing if we are doing it because we have free will. which is why i believe libertarians have more hidden errors. Whats more complex about the determinists theory is there arin't any errors because it expalins that we do stuff because of the envierment in which we are rasied in so there wouldn't be any errors to prove.
(D) yes some theories from determinists are more consistent than libertarians. Determinists therios are more consistant than libertarians because determinists do have errors unlike libertarians and libertarians dosen't really explain what is the purpose of our actions.
1) Determinists and Libertarians are the most plausiable explanations of the ultimate causes of human actions.
2) Determinists has much more explantory breadth and simplicity,whereas libertarians has little more explanatory breadth, and therios one are more creative.
3) Therfore, Determinists is the best explanation of the causes of the human actions.
The free will debate is basiclly a debate on what is the ultimit cause of human actions. There are two different types of causes. The first type of cause is Libertarians which they believe some of our actions are generated by free will and soem of them are generated by external causes. The secound type of human action is called Determinists which believes all our actions are generated by external causes such as the phyical world or the enviorment one was raised. I believe that the determinists is more reasonable which is why i agree with the determinists beliefs.
(A) I believe that Determinists explain more types of Human behavior than libertarians. The reason why i believe that is if you think about if everyone had free will and wanted to do what they wanted alot of people would be the same type of person but since there is no free will this is why there is different people in the world. Even if there is free will people couldn't change there life if they wanted to because they think they did but they didn't like have you ever heard that saying everything happens for a reason that reason is because it was already suppose to happen people can't change what's going to happen to them even if they did it was meant to happen. The types of theoires that Libertarians fail to address is when you're doing somthing like playing video games or doing laundry why there doing it.
(B) Yes i believe that determinsts explain the causes of human behavior in greater detail the Libertarians. The reason why i believe this is because determinists expalin that everything is caused by external world and the eniverment one was raised and i agree with that because why else would be here no has a reason why we were brought to this world. And Libertarians just believe we do stuff just to do it basically which isn't really an explanation. Which is why i believe Derterminsts expalains the Human cause more.
(C) Yes some theories from libertarians have fewer parts than determinists and i say this because it dosen't give a reason on why we do stuff yes they say we have free will but what is the meaning of doing what were doing if we are doing it because we have free will. which is why i believe libertarians have more hidden errors. Whats more complex about the determinists theory is there arin't any errors because it expalins that we do stuff because of the envierment in which we are rasied in so there wouldn't be any errors to prove.
(D) yes some theories from determinists are more consistent than libertarians. Determinists therios are more consistant than libertarians because determinists do have errors unlike libertarians and libertarians dosen't really explain what is the purpose of our actions.
1) Determinists and Libertarians are the most plausiable explanations of the ultimate causes of human actions.
2) Determinists has much more explantory breadth and simplicity,whereas libertarians has little more explanatory breadth, and therios one are more creative.
3) Therfore, Determinists is the best explanation of the causes of the human actions.
In your essay you say "The reason why i believe this is because determinists expalin that everything is caused by external world and the eniverment one was raised and i agree with that because why else would be here no has a reason why we were brought to this world." this is confusing to me first you start by telling us about how our actions are determined by experience and then you shift quickly to the reason for our existence. Doesn't it make sense that we have the opportunity to choose how to respond to our environment? Many lose loved ones and some spiral down and lose themselves while pothers rise from this trauma. it is all based on the person and the choices they are willing to make.
ReplyDeleteYou have a good point when you state everything happens for a reason. Yes, that's a part of how life is but I think your argument on people being the same if everyone had free will is absurd. We are similar, biologically and physically, but we have certain traits that distinguishes us humans from each other and other species. With free will as an inference to how we act, does not cover all of our behaviors or mechanisms of what we produce, provide, and they way we are able to adapt, grow, and learn.
ReplyDelete